Menu

Butler Lumber Co Case Study Analysis

Case Study Solution And Analysis


Home >> Harvard >> Butler Lumber Co >>

Butler Lumber Co Case Study Analysis

Butler Lumber Co is currently among the greatest food chains worldwide. It was founded by Harvard in 1866, a German Pharmacist who first released "FarineLactee"; a mix of flour and milk to feed babies and decrease mortality rate. At the same time, the Page siblings from Switzerland likewise discovered The Anglo-Swiss Condensed Milk Company. The two became rivals initially however in the future combined in 1905, resulting in the birth of Butler Lumber Co.
Business is now a global business. Unlike other multinational business, it has senior executives from various countries and tries to make choices considering the whole world. Butler Lumber Co currently has more than 500 factories worldwide and a network spread throughout 86 countries.

Purpose

The function of Business Corporation is to enhance the quality of life of individuals by playing its part and providing healthy food. While making sure that the company is prospering in the long run, that's how it plays its part for a much better and healthy future

Vision

Butler Lumber Co's vision is to provide its clients with food that is healthy, high in quality and safe to eat. It wishes to be ingenious and all at once understand the requirements and requirements of its consumers. Its vision is to grow quick and provide products that would satisfy the requirements of each age group. Butler Lumber Co pictures to develop a trained workforce which would help the business to grow
.

Mission

Butler Lumber Co's objective is that as presently, it is the leading company in the food industry, it believes in 'Great Food, Great Life". Its mission is to provide its customers with a range of choices that are healthy and best in taste too. It is focused on providing the best food to its clients throughout the day and night.

Products.

Butler Lumber Co has a large range of items that it provides to its consumers. In 2011, Business was listed as the most gainful company.

Goals and Objectives

• Remembering the vision and objective of the corporation, the company has set its objectives and objectives. These objectives and goals are noted below.
• One goal of the company is to reach zero land fill status. (Business, aboutus, 2017).
• Another goal of Butler Lumber Co is to waste minimum food during production. Frequently, the food produced is squandered even before it reaches the clients.
• Another thing that Business is dealing with is to enhance its product packaging in such a method that it would help it to lower those issues and would also ensure the shipment of high quality of its products to its consumers.
• Meet international requirements of the environment.
• Construct a relationship based upon trust with its consumers, organisation partners, employees, and government.

Critical Issues

Just Recently, Business Company is focusing more towards the strategy of NHW and investing more of its earnings on the R&D innovation. The nation is investing more on acquisitions and mergers to support its NHW method. Nevertheless, the target of the company is not attained as the sales were anticipated to grow greater at the rate of 10% annually and the operating margins to increase by 20%, given in Exhibition H. There is a need to focus more on the sales then the development technology. Otherwise, it might result in the decreased profits rate. (Henderson, 2012).

Situational Analysis.

Analysis of Current Strategy, Vision and Goals

The existing Business method is based on the concept of Nutritious, Health and Wellness (NHW). This method deals with the idea to bringing change in the client preferences about food and making the food stuff healthier worrying about the health problems.
The vision of this technique is based on the key approach i.e. 60/40+ which merely implies that the items will have a score of 60% on the basis of taste and 40% is based on its nutritional value. The items will be produced with extra dietary value in contrast to all other products in market acquiring it a plus on its dietary material.
This technique was adopted to bring more tasty plus nutritious foods and drinks in market than ever. In competitors with other business, with an objective of keeping its trust over customers as Business Company has actually acquired more relied on by clients.

Quantitative Analysis.

R&D Spending as a percentage of sales are declining with increasing real amount of costs reveals that the sales are increasing at a greater rate than its R&D spending, and enable the business to more invest in R&D.
Net Revenue Margin is increasing while R&D as a portion of sales is declining. This indication also reveals a green light to the R&D spending, mergers and acquisitions.
Financial obligation ratio of the company is increasing due to its costs on mergers, acquisitions and R&D advancement instead of payment of debts. This increasing financial obligation ratio present a threat of default of Business to its investors and might lead a decreasing share costs. In terms of increasing financial obligation ratio, the company should not spend much on R&D and ought to pay its present financial obligations to reduce the danger for financiers.
The increasing danger of investors with increasing financial obligation ratio and declining share costs can be observed by huge decline of EPS of Butler Lumber Co stocks.
The sales development of business is likewise low as compare to its mergers and acquisitions due to slow perception structure of consumers. This sluggish development likewise hinder company to more spend on its mergers and acquisitions.( Business, Business Financial Reports, 2006-2010).
Keep in mind: All the above analysis is done on the basis of calculations and Graphs given in the Exhibitions D and E.

TWOS Analysis


2 analysis can be utilized to derive numerous methods based upon the SWOT Analysis offered above. A short summary of TWOS Analysis is given up Display H.

Strategies to exploit Opportunities using Strengths

Business should introduce more ingenious products by big quantity of R&D Spending and mergers and acquisitions. It might increase the market share of Business and increase the revenue margins for the business. It could also provide Business a long term competitive benefit over its rivals.
The global expansion of Business should be concentrated on market capturing of developing nations by growth, bring in more clients through customer's commitment. As establishing countries are more populous than industrialized nations, it could increase the customer circle of Business.

Strategies to Overcome Weaknesses to Exploit Opportunities

Swot AnalysisButler Lumber Co needs to do careful acquisition and merger of companies, as it could impact the client's and society's perceptions about Business. It needs to get and merge with those business which have a market reputation of healthy and healthy business. It would enhance the understandings of customers about Business.
Business ought to not only invest its R&D on innovation, instead of it needs to also concentrate on the R&D spending over evaluation of cost of different healthy products. This would increase cost effectiveness of its products, which will lead to increasing its sales, due to declining costs, and margins.

Strategies to use strengths to overcome threats

Business must move to not only developing but also to developed nations. It should widen its circle to different nations like Unilever which runs in about 170 plus countries.

Strategies to overcome weaknesses to avoid threats

Butler Lumber Co ought to wisely control its acquisitions to avoid the danger of misunderstanding from the consumers about Business. It ought to obtain and combine with those nations having a goodwill of being a healthy business in the market. This would not just enhance the perception of customers about Business however would likewise increase the sales, earnings margins and market share of Business. It would likewise enable the business to use its potential resources effectively on its other operations instead of acquisitions of those organizations slowing the NHW method development.

Segmentation Analysis

Demographic Segmentation

The group division of Business is based upon four factors; age, gender, earnings and occupation. Business produces numerous items related to babies i.e. Cerelac, Nido, and so on and associated to grownups i.e. confectionary items. Butler Lumber Co products are quite inexpensive by nearly all levels, however its significant targeted clients, in terms of earnings level are middle and upper middle level customers.

Geographical Segmentation

Geographical segmentation of Business is composed of its existence in almost 86 nations. Its geographical division is based upon 2 primary aspects i.e. average income level of the customer along with the environment of the region. Singapore Business Business's segmentation is done on the basis of the weather condition of the region i.e. hot, warm or cold.

Psychographic Segmentation

Psychographic segmentation of Business is based upon the character and lifestyle of the customer. Business 3 in 1 Coffee target those consumers whose life style is rather busy and don't have much time.

Behavioral Segmentation

Butler Lumber Co behavioral division is based upon the attitude knowledge and awareness of the consumer. For instance its extremely healthy items target those clients who have a health mindful mindset towards their usages.

Butler Lumber Co Alternatives

In order to sustain the brand in the market and keep the customer intact with the brand, there are 2 options:
Option: 1
The Company should invest more on acquisitions than on the R&D.
Pros:
1. Acquisitions would increase total possessions of the company, increasing the wealth of the business. Nevertheless, costs on R&D would be sunk cost.
2. The business can resell the acquired systems in the market, if it fails to implement its strategy. However, quantity spend on the R&D might not be revived, and it will be thought about entirely sunk cost, if it do not offer prospective outcomes.
3. Spending on R&D provide slow development in sales, as it takes long period of time to introduce a product. However, acquisitions offer fast results, as it provide the company already developed item, which can be marketed soon after the acquisition.
Cons:
1. Acquisition of company's which do not fit with the business's values like Kraftz foods can lead the business to face misconception of consumers about Business core worths of healthy and nutritious products.
2 Large spending on acquisitions than R&D would send out a signal of company's inefficiency of developing innovative products, and would outcomes in consumer's dissatisfaction.
3. Big acquisitions than R&D would extend the line of product of the company by the products which are already present in the market, making company unable to introduce brand-new innovative items.
Option: 2.
The Company must spend more on its R&D rather than acquisitions.
Pros:
1. It would make it possible for the business to produce more ingenious products.
2. It would provide the business a strong competitive position in the market.
3. It would enable the company to increase its targeted consumers by introducing those items which can be used to a completely new market section.
4. Innovative items will offer long term benefits and high market share in long run.
Cons:
1. It would reduce the earnings margins of the company.
2. In case of failure, the entire spending on R&D would be thought about as sunk expense, and would affect the company at big. The danger is not in the case of acquisitions.
3. It would not increase the wealth of business, which might offer an unfavorable signal to the financiers, and could result I declining stock prices.
Alternative 3:
Continue its acquisitions and mergers with considerable spending on in R&D Program.
Vrio AnalysisPros:
1. It would permit the company to present new ingenious products with less threat of converting the spending on R&D into sunk expense.
2. It would provide a favorable signal to the investors, as the overall possessions of the business would increase with its substantial R&D costs.
3. It would not impact the earnings margins of the business at a big rate as compare to alternative 2.
4. It would offer the company a strong long term market position in regards to the company's total wealth as well as in regards to innovative products.
Cons:
1. Threat of conversion of R&D costs into sunk expense, greater than option 1 lesser than alternative 2.
2. Danger of misconception about the acquisitions, greater than alternative 2 and lower than alternative 1.
3. Intro of less number of innovative products than alternative 2 and high number of ingenious items than alternative 1.

Butler Lumber Co Conclusion

RecommendationsBusiness has stayed the top market gamer for more than a years. It has institutionalized its strategies and culture to align itself with the market modifications and client habits, which has ultimately enabled it to sustain its market share. Though, Business has actually established considerable market share and brand identity in the city markets, it is advised that the company ought to concentrate on the backwoods in terms of establishing brand loyalty, awareness, and equity, such can be done by creating a specific brand name allotment strategy through trade marketing methods, that draw clear distinction between Butler Lumber Co items and other competitor products. Moreover, Business needs to leverage its brand picture of safe and healthy food in catering the rural markets and likewise to upscale the offerings in other classifications such as nutrition. This will allow the company to develop brand name equity for recently presented and already produced products on a higher platform, making the efficient use of resources and brand name image in the market.

Butler Lumber Co Exhibits

PESTEL Analysis
P
Political
E
Economic
S
Social
T
Technology
L
Legal
E
Environment
Governmental assistance

Transforming standards of international food.
Improved market share. Altering assumption towards much healthier items Improvements in R&D and also QA departments.

Intro of E-marketing.
No such effect as it is beneficial. Issues over recycling.

Use resources.

Competitor Analysis
Business Unilever PLC Kraft Foods Incorporation DANONE
Sales Growth Highest because 3000 Greatest after Service with less development than Organisation 4th Most affordable
R&D Spending Highest possible since 2005 Highest after Business 7th Least expensive
Net Profit Margin Highest given that 2008 with rapid development from 2003 to 2016 Because of sale of Alcon in 2019. Nearly equal to Kraft Foods Unification Nearly equal to Unilever N/A
Competitive Advantage Food with Nourishment and health and wellness variable Highest possible number of brands with sustainable practices Biggest confectionary and also refined foods brand in the world Largest milk products and also mineral water brand name on the planet
Segmentation Center and also upper middle degree consumers worldwide Specific customers along with home group All age and Revenue Customer Teams Middle and also top center degree consumers worldwide
Number of Brands 3rd 4th 7th 7th

Quantitative Analysis​
Analysis of Financial Statements (In Millions of CHF)
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Sales Revenue 55278 512972 687193 584529 762415
Net Profit Margin 9.11% 3.61% 24.26% 6.42% 93.15%
EPS (Earning Per Share) 81.72 5.91 8.95 7.87 47.88
Total Asset 576634 683415 545559 849612 75267
Total Debt 53788 15197 48295 16764 31738
Debt Ratio 61% 31% 53% 95% 55%
R&D Spending 2977 9749 1333 1824 7422
R&D Spending as % of Sales 2.15% 9.53% 7.31% 5.21% 1.83%

Executive Summary Swot Analysis Vrio Analysis Pestel Analysis
Porters Analysis Recommendations