Menu

The Scotts Company B Developing A Supply Chain Balanced Scorecard Case Study Solution

Case Study Solution And Analysis


Home >> Chicago Booth >> The Scotts Company B Developing A Supply Chain Balanced Scorecard >>

The Scotts Company B Developing A Supply Chain Balanced Scorecard Case Study Help

The Scotts Company B Developing A Supply Chain Balanced Scorecard is presently one of the most significant food cycle worldwide. It was established by Chicago Booth in 1866, a German Pharmacist who initially introduced "FarineLactee"; a combination of flour and milk to feed babies and decrease death rate. At the exact same time, the Page bros from Switzerland likewise found The Anglo-Swiss Condensed Milk Company. The 2 ended up being rivals in the beginning but in the future merged in 1905, leading to the birth of The Scotts Company B Developing A Supply Chain Balanced Scorecard.
Business is now a global company. Unlike other multinational companies, it has senior executives from different nations and tries to make decisions considering the entire world. The Scotts Company B Developing A Supply Chain Balanced Scorecard currently has more than 500 factories worldwide and a network spread throughout 86 nations.

Purpose

The purpose of The Scotts Company B Developing A Supply Chain Balanced Scorecard Corporation is to improve the lifestyle of individuals by playing its part and providing healthy food. It wishes to help the world in forming a healthy and much better future for it. It also wants to motivate people to live a healthy life. While making certain that the company is prospering in the long run, that's how it plays its part for a better and healthy future

Vision

The Scotts Company B Developing A Supply Chain Balanced Scorecard's vision is to provide its clients with food that is healthy, high in quality and safe to consume. It wishes to be ingenious and simultaneously understand the requirements and requirements of its clients. Its vision is to grow quickly and provide products that would satisfy the needs of each age. The Scotts Company B Developing A Supply Chain Balanced Scorecard visualizes to establish a well-trained workforce which would help the business to grow
.

Mission

The Scotts Company B Developing A Supply Chain Balanced Scorecard's objective is that as currently, it is the leading company in the food industry, it believes in 'Excellent Food, Good Life". Its objective is to supply its customers with a range of choices that are healthy and best in taste. It is focused on providing the very best food to its consumers throughout the day and night.

Products.

The Scotts Company B Developing A Supply Chain Balanced Scorecard has a broad range of items that it uses to its consumers. In 2011, Business was noted as the most rewarding organization.

Goals and Objectives

• Remembering the vision and mission of the corporation, the business has put down its objectives and goals. These goals and objectives are listed below.
• One goal of the business is to reach zero garbage dump status. It is working toward zero waste, where no waste of the factory is landfilled. It encourages its staff members to take the most out of the spin-offs. (Business, aboutus, 2017).
• Another objective of The Scotts Company B Developing A Supply Chain Balanced Scorecard is to squander minimum food during production. Frequently, the food produced is wasted even prior to it reaches the customers.
• Another thing that Business is dealing with is to improve its packaging in such a method that it would help it to reduce those complications and would also ensure the delivery of high quality of its products to its customers.
• Meet global standards of the environment.
• Construct a relationship based upon trust with its customers, company partners, staff members, and government.

Critical Issues

Recently, Business Business is focusing more towards the strategy of NHW and investing more of its earnings on the R&D technology. The country is investing more on acquisitions and mergers to support its NHW method. The target of the business is not achieved as the sales were anticipated to grow greater at the rate of 10% per year and the operating margins to increase by 20%, given in Exhibit H.

Situational Analysis.

Analysis of Current Strategy, Vision and Goals

The current Business technique is based on the idea of Nutritious, Health and Wellness (NHW). This strategy deals with the idea to bringing modification in the consumer choices about food and making the food things healthier concerning about the health issues.
The vision of this method is based upon the secret approach i.e. 60/40+ which merely indicates that the products will have a rating of 60% on the basis of taste and 40% is based on its nutritional value. The items will be manufactured with extra dietary value in contrast to all other items in market gaining it a plus on its dietary content.
This method was embraced to bring more tasty plus nutritious foods and beverages in market than ever. In competition with other business, with an intention of maintaining its trust over clients as Business Company has gotten more relied on by costumers.

Quantitative Analysis.

R&D Costs as a percentage of sales are decreasing with increasing real quantity of spending reveals that the sales are increasing at a higher rate than its R&D costs, and allow the business to more invest in R&D.
Net Revenue Margin is increasing while R&D as a portion of sales is declining. This sign also shows a thumbs-up to the R&D spending, mergers and acquisitions.
Financial obligation ratio of the company is increasing due to its spending on mergers, acquisitions and R&D development instead of payment of debts. This increasing debt ratio position a hazard of default of Business to its investors and could lead a declining share prices. For that reason, in terms of increasing debt ratio, the firm must not spend much on R&D and ought to pay its current financial obligations to reduce the risk for investors.
The increasing danger of investors with increasing financial obligation ratio and decreasing share rates can be observed by substantial decrease of EPS of The Scotts Company B Developing A Supply Chain Balanced Scorecard stocks.
The sales development of business is likewise low as compare to its mergers and acquisitions due to slow understanding structure of customers. This sluggish growth likewise prevent business to additional invest in its mergers and acquisitions.( Business, Business Financial Reports, 2006-2010).
Note: All the above analysis is done on the basis of calculations and Charts given in the Exhibits D and E.

TWOS Analysis


2 analysis can be used to derive various methods based on the SWOT Analysis provided above. A short summary of TWOS Analysis is given up Display H.

Strategies to exploit Opportunities using Strengths

Business should present more ingenious products by large amount of R&D Costs and mergers and acquisitions. It could increase the market share of Business and increase the revenue margins for the business. It could likewise supply Business a long term competitive benefit over its competitors.
The global expansion of Business ought to be focused on market capturing of developing nations by expansion, bring in more consumers through client's commitment. As establishing nations are more populated than developed countries, it might increase the customer circle of Business.

Strategies to Overcome Weaknesses to Exploit Opportunities

Swot AnalysisThe Scotts Company B Developing A Supply Chain Balanced Scorecard needs to do mindful acquisition and merger of organizations, as it could impact the client's and society's understandings about Business. It should get and merge with those business which have a market credibility of healthy and healthy business. It would enhance the perceptions of customers about Business.
Business must not just invest its R&D on development, instead of it should also focus on the R&D spending over assessment of cost of different healthy items. This would increase expense performance of its items, which will result in increasing its sales, due to declining costs, and margins.

Strategies to use strengths to overcome threats

Business needs to move to not only developing however also to developed nations. It should broaden its circle to different nations like Unilever which runs in about 170 plus countries.

Strategies to overcome weaknesses to avoid threats

It needs to obtain and merge with those nations having a goodwill of being a healthy business in the market. It would also enable the company to utilize its potential resources effectively on its other operations rather than acquisitions of those companies slowing the NHW strategy development.

Segmentation Analysis

Demographic Segmentation

The group segmentation of Business is based on four factors; age, gender, earnings and profession. Business produces a number of items related to infants i.e. Cerelac, Nido, and so on and related to adults i.e. confectionary products. The Scotts Company B Developing A Supply Chain Balanced Scorecard products are rather affordable by nearly all levels, however its major targeted customers, in terms of earnings level are middle and upper middle level consumers.

Geographical Segmentation

Geographical segmentation of Business is composed of its existence in practically 86 nations. Its geographical division is based upon 2 primary factors i.e. typical income level of the customer as well as the environment of the region. For instance, Singapore Business Company's division is done on the basis of the weather of the region i.e. hot, warm or cold.

Psychographic Segmentation

Psychographic segmentation of Business is based upon the character and lifestyle of the consumer. Business 3 in 1 Coffee target those customers whose life style is rather hectic and do not have much time.

Behavioral Segmentation

The Scotts Company B Developing A Supply Chain Balanced Scorecard behavioral segmentation is based upon the mindset understanding and awareness of the customer. Its extremely nutritious items target those consumers who have a health conscious attitude towards their usages.

The Scotts Company B Developing A Supply Chain Balanced Scorecard Alternatives

In order to sustain the brand in the market and keep the consumer undamaged with the brand name, there are 2 options:
Alternative: 1
The Business ought to invest more on acquisitions than on the R&D.
Pros:
1. Acquisitions would increase total possessions of the company, increasing the wealth of the business. Nevertheless, costs on R&D would be sunk expense.
2. The business can resell the acquired units in the market, if it fails to execute its method. Amount invest on the R&D could not be restored, and it will be thought about entirely sunk expense, if it do not provide prospective outcomes.
3. Investing in R&D offer sluggish growth in sales, as it takes long time to present an item. Acquisitions offer quick outcomes, as it provide the business currently established product, which can be marketed quickly after the acquisition.
Cons:
1. Acquisition of company's which do not fit with the business's worths like Kraftz foods can lead the company to deal with mistaken belief of consumers about Business core worths of healthy and healthy products.
2 Big costs on acquisitions than R&D would send a signal of business's inadequacy of developing innovative items, and would lead to customer's frustration also.
3. Big acquisitions than R&D would extend the product line of the business by the products which are already present in the market, making company not able to introduce new ingenious products.
Option: 2.
The Business should spend more on its R&D rather than acquisitions.
Pros:
1. It would make it possible for the company to produce more ingenious products.
2. It would provide the company a strong competitive position in the market.
3. It would enable the business to increase its targeted customers by introducing those products which can be provided to a completely brand-new market segment.
4. Innovative items will supply long term benefits and high market share in long run.
Cons:
1. It would decrease the profit margins of the company.
2. In case of failure, the entire spending on R&D would be considered as sunk expense, and would impact the business at large. The risk is not in the case of acquisitions.
3. It would not increase the wealth of company, which might supply an unfavorable signal to the financiers, and could result I declining stock rates.
Alternative 3:
Continue its acquisitions and mergers with considerable spending on in R&D Program.
Vrio AnalysisPros:
1. It would enable the business to present brand-new innovative products with less danger of transforming the spending on R&D into sunk cost.
2. It would supply a positive signal to the financiers, as the overall properties of the business would increase with its substantial R&D costs.
3. It would not affect the profit margins of the company at a big rate as compare to alternative 2.
4. It would offer the business a strong long term market position in regards to the business's total wealth in addition to in regards to innovative items.
Cons:
1. Danger of conversion of R&D costs into sunk expense, higher than alternative 1 lower than alternative 2.
2. Threat of misunderstanding about the acquisitions, greater than alternative 2 and lower than option 1.
3. Intro of less variety of ingenious items than alternative 2 and high number of innovative products than alternative 1.

The Scotts Company B Developing A Supply Chain Balanced Scorecard Conclusion

RecommendationsBusiness has actually stayed the leading market player for more than a decade. It has institutionalized its methods and culture to align itself with the market modifications and consumer behavior, which has eventually enabled it to sustain its market share. Though, Business has developed considerable market share and brand name identity in the city markets, it is recommended that the company should concentrate on the rural areas in regards to establishing brand commitment, awareness, and equity, such can be done by creating a particular brand name allowance strategy through trade marketing tactics, that draw clear difference in between The Scotts Company B Developing A Supply Chain Balanced Scorecard items and other rival products. The Scotts Company B Developing A Supply Chain Balanced Scorecard should leverage its brand name image of safe and healthy food in catering the rural markets and likewise to upscale the offerings in other categories such as nutrition. This will enable the business to establish brand name equity for newly introduced and already produced products on a higher platform, making the efficient usage of resources and brand name image in the market.

The Scotts Company B Developing A Supply Chain Balanced Scorecard Exhibits

PESTEL Analysis
P
Political
E
Economic
S
Social
T
Technology
L
Legal
E
Environment
Governmental support

Altering criteria of global food.
Improved market share.
Changing perception towards much healthier items
Improvements in R&D as well as QA divisions.

Introduction of E-marketing.
No such effect as it is beneficial.
Problems over recycling.

Use sources.

Competitor Analysis
Business Unilever PLC Kraft Foods Incorporation DANONE
Sales Growth Highest possible because 5000
Greatest after Service with less growth than Business 3rd Most affordable
R&D Spending Highest possible considering that 2003 Highest possible after Service 7th Lowest
Net Profit Margin Highest possible because 2007 with fast growth from 2005 to 2015 Because of sale of Alcon in 2018. Virtually equal to Kraft Foods Incorporation Almost equal to Unilever N/A
Competitive Advantage Food with Nourishment and health and wellness factor Highest possible variety of brands with sustainable techniques Largest confectionary as well as refined foods brand name worldwide Largest dairy items and mineral water brand name worldwide
Segmentation Middle and also upper center level customers worldwide Specific customers in addition to family team All age as well as Income Consumer Teams Center and upper center degree customers worldwide
Number of Brands 6th 4th 9th 4th

Quantitative Analysis​
Analysis of Financial Statements (In Millions of CHF)
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Sales Revenue 71846 573953 426695 258236 783191
Net Profit Margin 1.27% 1.86% 53.22% 6.46% 68.57%
EPS (Earning Per Share) 31.89 3.62 2.14 1.29 36.24
Total Asset 186449 371261 846152 289986 61379
Total Debt 81711 16155 65342 76837 61686
Debt Ratio 99% 21% 84% 29% 28%
R&D Spending 6232 8724 3938 3338 3275
R&D Spending as % of Sales 9.94% 5.25% 4.97% 4.65% 1.74%

The Scotts Company B Developing A Supply Chain Balanced Scorecard Executive Summary The Scotts Company B Developing A Supply Chain Balanced Scorecard Swot Analysis The Scotts Company B Developing A Supply Chain Balanced Scorecard Vrio Analysis The Scotts Company B Developing A Supply Chain Balanced Scorecard Pestel Analysis
The Scotts Company B Developing A Supply Chain Balanced Scorecard Porters Analysis The Scotts Company B Developing A Supply Chain Balanced Scorecard Recommendations